Image for Q: What Are Men Really Hungry For? (Part 2)

Q: What Are Men Really Hungry For? (Part 2)

Photo of John CaldwellJohn Caldwell | Bio

John Caldwell

Dr. John Caldwell served Kingsway Christian Church of Avon, Indiana, as senior pastor for 36 years, retiring in 2010. During those years, KCC progressed from a small, infant congregation to a thriving megachurch. John has authored five books, has written dozens of published articles, and served as president of both North American Christian Convention and the International Conference on Missions. He has traveled in over 100 countries and ministered alongside missionaries in more than 25. John has been married to Jan since 1965, and they are parents to Shan and Jennifer. John presently leads John Caldwell Ministries, preaching, teaching, and holding seminars, with an emphasis on ministry on the mission field.
Photo of Lee KeeleLee Keele | Bio

Lee Keele

Lee and Ginger Keele have been married and ministering together for over 27 years. Life is an adventure with 5 children; the two youngest still at home, and two in college. Lee has degrees in Bible and Ministry from Oklahoma Christian University and is currently working toward a Master of Business Administration. Passionate about teaching, preaching, and making disciples, Lee continues to enjoy working with the local church. Together, Lee and Ginger have experience in adult ministries, youth, and children's ministries, and have partnered together in missions and several overseas mission trips.
Photo of Jared EllisJared Ellis | Bio

Jared Ellis

Jared is the preaching minister at Fellowship Regional Church in Iola, KS, with a satellite campus in Caney, KS. He is also the host of a long-form interview podcast show called The Homilist, which explores the various aspects of preaching. 

*Editor’s Note: What are some things that men deeply hunger for, which can be met through discipling relationships with other men? We asked a panel of men who have discipled other men before, and below is Part 2 of their answers. For Part 1, click here.

A: Men Need to Experience Conversion

By John Caldwell

Let me start with the most basic issue of all, a personal relationship with Christ as Lord and Savior.

I hesitate to say this lest I be misunderstood and my orthodoxy be questioned; but I fear that many professing Christians have yet to experience genuine conversion. We of the Restoration Movement have so emphasized the importance of baptism, that at least some of us have failed to emphasize the importance of saving faith, repentance, and a genuine surrender to the Lordship of Christ.

I find this reflected in the growing absence of such Biblical terminology as being “born again,” “saved,” “converted,” “added to their number by the Lord,” etc.

I know that the number of baptisms is certainly something we can objectively report; and it is certainly not for me to judge anyone’s heart. Furthermore, I rejoice in reports of large numbers being baptized, assuming genuine conversion. After all, 3,000 were baptized on Pentecost. But if the emphasis is that of the water, is it not possible that many reported baptisms are those of people who went down dry sinners and came up wet ones?

Now, how does this relate to the question at hand? I believe there is a deep longing, often denied, within the heart of all people, male and female, for a personal relationship with their Creator.

I fear that longing is sometimes not fulfilled when people have a relationship with a church but not the living Savior. Even when that relationship is fulfilled, there is a need for community, for those with whom a person can share both their fulfillment and their struggles. It is especially important and difficult for men to be able to relate with other Christian men on a deep and honest level. In that regard many men struggle; many are lonely.

A: Men Need Intentional Accountability

By Lee Keele

Geoff (fictional name) was a part of our accountability group. At first, he would miss a meeting or two usually with some excuse about being busy doing this or that. And at first, the rest of us didn’t give it much thought. After all, he seemed to be doing fine? Or so he’d say. Over time, he started missing without any excuse at all. No phone call. No heads up. No nothing.

We tried to reach out, but his avoidance became more pronounced over a period of weeks, then months. After a time, it just became awkward to even see him in public. “Hey Geoff, how are ya?” “Fine. You?” “Good. Kids doing okay?” Yeah. Yours?” ‘Blah blah blah.”

What happened?

What happened is that we were practicing poor accountability. That is to say, we had made our mutual desire to overcome the sin in our lives the centerpiece of our accountability.

“How’d you do this week?” “Any sinful thoughts?” “Any struggles?” “When? Did you journal it?” “Did you stumble this week?” “What are you doing to try better? Do better? Be better?”

I may be overstating the point, but I don’t think so.

Through this experience, and some good conversation, we were able to turn things around. We learned: When you make accountability for sin the centerpiece of small group activity, you create the potential to either ruin friendships, or make better liars of people. That’s what happened with Geoff. I don’t think it was entirely his fault.

Things for our group turned a corner when we began to supply what I now call “Intentional Accountability.”

Intentional accountability is not about being accountable for our sin, though it does provide an avenue for that when and if it is necessary. But rather than placing sin at the center of our effort–instead of coming together to try and “not” do something–we place God’s calling on our lives at the center.

“What is God calling you to do? What steps can we help you make to get you there? What tools do you need? What opportunities? How can we, your brothers in Christ help you get there?”

What we discovered is simple: When we stay on task with God around His calling on our lives, we begin to find the motivation we need to say no to the sin in our lives.

Men need accountability. For sin? Sure. But more importantly, for becoming the men God calls us to be.

A: Men Need to See Blood

By Jared Ellis

It isn’t enough to just allude to your sin; in fact, it’s disobedience. You don’t have to like what I’m about to say, but it doesn’t make it any less true.
Even if people see you as a moral giant, a spiritual specialist–even if you’re a pastor–you know the truth: You are a man. You are sinner. You sometimes struggle to avert your eyes. You eat too much. You avoid hard conversations. You have taken the path of least resistance. You have been nice when you should have been honest.

The only reason we allude to our sin, rather than confessing it, is because we want others to think more highly of us.

Here is the problem: We then grow weary and complain, tired of seeing the men in our churches fall asleep in sermons, refuse to grow, and neglect the spiritual responsibilities of their home.
Can we actually be angry at others when they believe our lies? Wasn’t the goal to hold the standard so outrageously high that others would only assume the best of us? Now we’re mad about it? We’ve postured as Superman and then we’re upset that nobody else will do anything?

If you want to move men to action, show them blood, your blood.

They are searching for something that looks like them, only redeemed. Stop thinking “incarnation” and start thinking “resurrection.” We aren’t God that we would experience the former, but we can and must let others experience us daily in the latter. To model some version of pseudo-incarnation doesn’t offer hope to anyone.
Men move at the sight of blood. Let James 5:16 serve as a rusty box cutter on your soul and watch men come running toward you.
You think it might be time to put your cape back in the phone booth, get your suit back on, stop wearing your blue and red pajamas to work? Good, it was starting to get weird.