I started ministering to Muslims around 2014, almost 13 years ago. Most of what I did was to help Christians understand what Muslims believe and how to reach out to them. But things have changed drastically since Oct. 7, 2023 when Hamas committed a genocidal act against the Jewish people in Israel. The Islamist narrative has gained greater influence than ever before, through groups like the Muslim Brotherhood. Given the influence of social media, Muslims now have greater access to Islamic apologetics. What’s more, interfaith relationships have taken on new religious and political dimensions.
During these years, I studied Islam with Muslim and non-Muslim scholars. This experience also allowed me to build friendships within Muslim communities, which helped me train Christians to communicate their faith. However, the events following October 7, 2023 challenged some assumptions I had developed over years of Muslim ministry. It took me a while to learn this, but knowing someone for many years and discussing religion doesn’t necessarily mean you understand how deeply politics and ideology can influence their beliefs and views of world events.
Social Media and the Growth of Islamic Apologetics
Muslims used to practice their faith much like pre-Vatican II Catholics did: questions were filtered through the priest, and parishioners sought little knowledge of the faith beyond that. Social media Imam influencers have changed that, and the predominant voices shaping the faith are no longer local Imams, but influencers and religious scholars such as Yasir Qadhi and Hamza Yusuf, and educators like Omar Suleiman, who leads the Yaqeen Institute. Then there are apologists such as Daniel Haqiqatjou, activists like Nihad Awad and Linda Sarsour, and political leaders that include Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib, who influence many Muslims according to this view. These voices represent varying levels of an Islamist narrative that is propagated and helps shape such things as Muslim religious identity, their attitudes toward Western society, and how public engagement is done. Christians are now engaging with Muslims who may have learned more about Islam from YouTube than from their local Muslim communities.
“Christians are now engaging with Muslims who may have learned more about Islam from YouTube than from their local Muslim communities.”
Through YouTube, podcasts, and social media, Muslims can access Islamic apologetics without studying under a religious scholar. There are many arguments against the Trinity, the deity of Christ, the Bible being true, and Christ dying on the cross. Now, Muslims have learned how to explain these difficult arguments to normal people. This means Christians must be prepared to respond not with canned answers, but with a solid understanding of Scripture and Christian doctrine.
Islamism, Religious Identity, and Political Activism
Another trend to be aware of is Islamism. Islamism is when Muslims seek to apply Islamic values to the political sphere. Of course, not all Muslims are Islamists, and, for that matter, there are various types of Islamists. It is important to understand that many Muslim groups in the West have been influenced by the Muslim Brotherhood, as the Muslim Brotherhood seeks to communicate Islam in a unified voice. According to a 2010 study by the Pew Research Center, members of the Muslim Brotherhood helped start many Muslim organizations in North America such as ISNA and CAIR, among others.
In November 2025, the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP) released The Muslim Brotherhood’s Strategic Entryism into the United States: A Systemic Analysis, which is a paper that outlines how Brotherhood networks have tried to take over Western institutions through such avenues as the educational system, politics, and civic organizations.
“Islamism is when Muslims seek to apply Islamic values to the political sphere.”
My Wake-Up Call After October 7
After October 7th, these issues became more personal for me. This unveiling came about when I was in London on the same day Hamas attacked Israel. In response to the attacks, I began speaking out against Hamas and expressing my support for Israel. When I did that, almost all of my Muslim friends in the UK turned on me or instantly cut ties.
I would have similar conversations during the week of October 7 in London with Uber drivers. I took 22 Uber rides during my time in Britain, 18 of which led to some type of debate, motivated by them, not me. Through those conversations, I realized something religious and political hung over them. At one point, it seemed they felt like Allah had blessed the Muslims through this catastrophe, a fact I found frightening. 
Again, I’m not saying all British Muslims felt this way, but what I witnessed was very disturbing, and I am convinced it was representative of much of the Muslim community.
“It seemed they felt like Allah had blessed the Muslims through this catastrophe, a fact I found frightening.”
After coming back to the US, I sat down with Muslim leaders in my city to discuss October 7. When I asked a poignant question about Hamas, each said, almost in unison, that Hamas were freedom fighters. The people I had built friendships with all these years were telling me that people could call the murder of Israelis “freedom fighting.” I began to realize that Islamism has a grip on Muslims in the West just as it does in Muslim nations. Through these conversations, I came to believe that many Muslims have been influenced by political ideologies, and that Christians should take this into consideration when engaging with Muslims today.
Progressives Provide the Vocabulary, & Muslims Supply the Narrative
Since October 7, I have listened to enough progressives, university students, and their faculty to notice a troubling pattern. While my examples are anecdotal, they do suggest a progressive vocabulary that is second nature to many people when discussing Israel and Palestine. This vocabulary includes concepts such as oppression, colonialism, indigenous rights, resistance, liberation, and decolonization. Their rhetoric lacks an understanding of the historical, religious, and political narratives underlying the conflict.
I think progressivism offers language that Westerners can understand, and Islamism uses that language to reflect an Islamic narrative. The focus of this vocabulary is directed only toward the West and Israel, the two obstacles to restoring Muslim greatness on a global scale. Ideas such as Muslim rule, why Jerusalem and Al-Aqsa matter, and opposition to Jewish rule can be associated with Western progressive values. This alliance between the left and Islamists allows progressives to learn these values from an Islamist standpoint while believing they are simply implementing progressive politics. So when you make a political statement through Western ideals of social justice, you may also be conveying religious ideas about sovereignty and Jewish claims to the land.
“I think progressivism offers language that Westerners can understand, and Islamism uses that language to reflect an Islamic narrative.”
What About Interfaith?
I have been involved in interfaith work for many years, albeit from an evangelical theological point of view. But after October 7, I began to ask myself what interfaith dialogue is trying to accomplish. I ran across a book titled Interfaith Dialogue: A Guide for Muslims by Muhammad Shafiq and Mohammed Abu-Nimer. The Muslim authors discuss how Muslims can learn from the Jewish experience in the West to help further Muslim influence. After the Holocaust, Jews integrated into Western society. One way they did this was by participating in interfaith relationships. The interfaith dynamic consisted primarily of Jews and Christians because Muslims did not begin arriving in large numbers until after the Hart-Celler Immigration Act of 1965 opened the door for increased Muslim immigration.
By doing so, Jews gained acceptance while maintaining their faith, and Muslims should follow in these footsteps. The authors go on to say that working with Jews can also allow Muslims to create coalitions that will benefit them politically. This shows that interfaith work can build understanding between religions and can also be used as a tactic to gain social acceptance. Therefore, what Christians need to understand is that interfaith dialogue may have motives beyond seeking genuine understanding between religions.
“Interfaith dialogue may have motives beyond seeking genuine understanding between religions.”
I recently asked Muslim scholar Ismail Royer, director of the Islam and Religious Freedom Action Team, about this. What I wanted to know was if Muslims were using interfaith dialogue as a tool to gain influence in Western society or if it was purely for religious reasons. He said that he believes Muslims should become more involved in politics, but it should be for the common good and not to push one religion’s views above others.
Unfortunately, this commitment to the common good is too often overshadowed by the desire to advance Islam in every area of life, a belief held by many Muslims. As Christians, we need to ask ourselves why we are building these relationships with Muslims and whether we are staying true to our calling to stand for truth and witness for Christ. Interfaith dialogue should never cause Christians to deny or alter the gospel or deny truth to gain favor or unity with others.
The Gospel Hasn’t Changed
We are called to be prepared to answer everyone who asks why we have hope, but to do so with gentleness and respect (1 Peter 3:15). The world has changed since October 7, but my desire to reach Muslims with the gospel hasn’t. We don’t have to fear Muslims but should be knowledgeable about their beliefs. Knowing more about Islam and Islamism should strengthen our desire to reach Muslims with the gospel, not diminish our love for them. This means that pastors in particular and Christians in general need to be prepared to understand not only Islamic beliefs but also the political and cultural influences that shape how Muslims understand the world. This strategy includes asking thoughtful questions, listening carefully, and responding to Muslims with biblical truth.
For more from Tim Orr and helping churches engage with Muslims, check out his Substack HERE. Used by permission.